Kurt baier professor of philosophy university of pittsburgh 1 baier. Since they are backwardlooking, they are not concerned with the possibility of a person committing a crime. Theories of punishment with special focus on reformative theory. Raskolnikov, a student, decides to kill a worthless person to help his impoverished family, and to prove that he is exempt from moral law. For punishment to be meted out, a person must be found guilty. Capital punishment capital punishment refers to the use of the death penalty as punishment for certain crimes. Thus fines and noncustodial sentences may address the crimes seen as least serious, with lengthy imprisonment or in some jurisdictions capital punishment reserved for.
Punishmentretribution, rehabilitation, and deterrence. The appeal of retributive justice as a theory of punishment rests in part on direct intuitive support, in part on the claim that it is better than alternative accounts of punishment, and in part on arguments tying it to deeper moral principles. His parents were very hard working and deeply religious people, but so poor. The purpose of this book is to explore punishments from a comparative. Theories of punishment can be divided into two general philosophies. The strengths and limits of the theory of retributive. Theories of punishment international journal of engineering and.
That is, they look to the future in deciding what to do in the present. Theories of punishment legal definition of theories of. Philosophical analysis of the theories of punishment in. This theory is commonly accepted at the present time, because it is in harmony with the humanitarian sentiments of the age. Agreement and kreen 2012 concluded in their study in botaswana against the use of corporal punishment in school. The unified theory of punishment is found in thom brooks, punishment routledge, 2012. The unified theory of punishment helps public policy decisionmaking and should be taken into account when we decide. Sep 02, 2014 the concept of penal reform had its birth from the reformative theory of punishment.
Retributive justice is a theory of punishment that when an offender breaks the law, justice requires that he or she suffer in return. It is based on the humanistic principle that even if an offender commits a crime, he does not cease to be a human being. The guilty deserve to be punished, and no moral consideration relevant to punishment outweighs the offenders criminal desert is the philosophy of retributive theory. Criminal punishment and the pursuit of justice harvard law school. The term crime does not, in modern criminal law, have any simple and universally accepted definition,1 though statutory definitions have been provided for. The prevailing features in the modern theory of punishment were developed by analytic philosophers half a century ago. Retributive theory of punishment vengeance theory it is a concept of primitive society which consists of injury inflicted by way of retaliation by victim of crime on actor of crime, which requires the existence of victim as well as a wrong doer. In other words, the monetary loss of the sufferer is compensated and the criminal has to compensate for the loss. Theories of punishment legal definition of theories of punishment. The incremental retributive impact of a death sentence. Must such a theory include the notion of an exact matching of punishment to crime. According to this theory the aim of punishment is to prevent or deter others from committing similar offences.
What links here related changes upload file special pages permanent link page. The first critical guide to examine all leading contemporary theories of punishment, this book explores among others the communicative theory of punishment, restorative justice, and the unified theory of punishment. Glaeser and bruce sacerdote april 2000 abstract does the economic model of optimal punishment e x plain the variation in the sentencing of murderers. Prevention of future crimes or rehabilitation of the offender are other purposes of punishment.
Modern theory of punishment modern theory of punishment is a combination of all the theories discussed above. The utilitarian authors will offer answers to such questions as. Punishment may take forms ranging from capital punishment, flogging, forced labour, and mutilation of the body to imprisonment and fines. Summary of research on the effects of corporal punishment.
Critical analysis of theories of punishment mere denunciation of crime is not enough. Retribution is different from revenge because retributive justice is directed only at. Stillman that hegel expounded a justification of punishment is clear. He should not be used as a means for the good of any other persons. The incremental retributive impact of a death sentence over life without parole michael l. A theory of the stability of punishment alfred blumstein and jacqueline cohen one of the more interesting theses advanced by durkheim, and subsequently by others, is that crime is a normal and not a pathological attribute of society provided that it attains and does. As the model predicts, we find that murderers with a high expected probability of recidivism receive longer.
After committing the crime, raskolnikov is overtaken by. There is a growing literature on the theories of punishment. Deterrence, incapacitation and ven geance edward l. Philosophical analysis of the theories of punishment in the. One can categorise crimes depending on the related punishment, with sentencing tariffs prescribed in line with the perceived seriousness of the offence. We discussed the first on april 15 and the second on april 20. In addition, we will give voice to some major objections to the utilitarian theory. Punishment means, it is the redress that the commonwealth takes against an offending member1punishment is some sort of social. If a vice is a crime, then how should it be punished. Kants theory of punishment utilitas cambridge core.
According to this theory, it does not matter whether or not the punishment will serve any purpose in future as utilitarian theory holds. A third theory also emphasizes the desert of the offender, but holds that what offenders deserve is the opportunity to reform. Mostly retributive justice seeks to punish a person for a crime in a way that is compensatory for the crime. After committing the crime, raskolnikov is overtaken by panic and tormented by conscience as, one by. Punishment theory and coherence michelle madden dempsey hom brooks is to be commended for having taken on an almost impossible task in writing his impressive new book, punishment.
The other presented what he called the expressive theory of punishment. What more could we want for an account of someones theory of punishment than his being the author of a book titled rationale of punishment. Though those years marked the ebb tide for the rehabilitative ideal of punishment and indeterminate ziptoten. Bradley when i worked for the manhattan district attorneys office in the early 1980s, criminal sentences were consistently and dramatically too lenient. The utilitarian theory of punishment seeks to punish offenders to discourage, or deter, future wrongdoing. General deterrence theory postulates that increasing the risk of apprehension and punishment in.
Rai, neetij, theories of punishment with special focus on reformative theory may 5, 2010. The unified theory provides us with the coherent framework that can justify their inclusion and illuminate their implementation in practice. Therefore, an effort should be made to reform himher during the period of hisher incarceration. Nov 04, 2015 theories of punishment can be divided into two general philosophies. According to this theory punishment is awarded with a view to prevent the offender from repeating the offence in future. A critical analysis of retributive punishment as a discipline. The retributive view of punishment is pastlooking which is paying back by the offender.
Punishment is the imposition of an undesirable or unpleasant outcome upon a group or. Retribution let the punishment fit the crime captures the essence of retribution. The object of punishment is to protect society from mischievous and undesirable elements by deterring potential offenders, by preventing the actual offenders from committing further offenses and by reforming and turning them into law abiding citizens. Governments have several theories to support the use of punishment to maintain order in society. According to this theory, the aim of punishment is to educate or reform the offender himself. The retributive theory seeks to punish offenders because they deserve to be punished.
It also requires that the response to a crime is proportional to the offence. Is it the case that retributivism requires its holders to. Theories of punishment and mandatory minimum sentences. Crime and punishment 2 of 967 translators preface a few words about dostoevsky himself may help the english reader to understand his work. Thom brooks examines several case studies in detail, including capital punishment, juvenile offending, and domestic abuse. May 06, 2010 the progress of civilization has resulted in the change in the theory, method and motive of punishment. In america, almost 20,000 persons have been legally put to death since colonial times, with most of the 96 capital punishment cbosworth. Brooks is more or less clear about what a theory of punishment is. Jan 10, 20 the first critical guide to examine all leading contemporary theories of punishment, this book explores among others the communicative theory of punishment, restorative justice, and the unified theory of punishment. The most widespread interpretation amongst contemporary theorists of kants theory of punishment is that it is retributivist.
Punishment can be used as a method of reducing the incidence of criminal behavior either by deterring the potential offenders or by incapacitating and preventing them from repeating the offence of by reforming them into lawabiding citizens. Theories of punishment are as follows i deterrent theory. Retributivist theory focusses on punishment to only those who deserve it. A theory of differential punishment vanderbilt university. The reformative aspect thinks of incorporating humane values into the prison system and the prison officials have to work for the achievement of the same. The reformative theory of punishment emphasises on reformation of offenders through the method of individualisation. Analysis of parentsteachers perception of the use of. Firstly, a kid who falls down and kicks the floor inadvertently. A different theory is that offenders take an unfair advantage over nonoffenders and punishment restores the just balance of benefits and burdens. On the contrary, i will argue there are very different senses in which kant discusses punishment. The type, logic, and details of his justification, however, are less clear.
In administration of criminal justice five theories of punishment have come into light. Theories of punishment with special focus on reformative. The strengths and limits of the theory of retributive punishment. Punishment means, it is the redress that the commonwealth takes against an offending member1punishment is. In the absence of punishment, there will be chaos, confusion and disorder in the state and the weak will be exploited and victimized by the strong. He endorses retribution for moral law transgressions and consequentialist considerations for positive law violations. General deterrence theory postulates that increasing the risk of apprehension and punishment in society deters members of society as a. Feb 28, 2017 modern theory of punishment modern theory of punishment is a combination of all the theories discussed above.
We find them asking whether this or that is an essential part of a retributive theory. Punishment may take forms ranging from capital punishment, flogging, forced labour, and mutilation of the body to imprisonment and. Process of punishment is essential for the smooth running of society. Perspectives on the effects of corporal punishment. May 27, 2010 theories of punishment and mandatory minimum sentences.
Prison of the time should have a meaning that incorporates the reformative values into it. We pay the penalty because we owe it, and for no other reason. His parents were very hard working and deeply religious people, but so poor that they lived with their five children in only two rooms. What is needed is a reassertion, reformulation, and redeployment of recognizably liberal ideas in the theory of punishment see the discussion below. Retributive justice stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. As a hybrid of utilitarian theory, deterrent theory of punishment is said to hold a high hope as it is expected to aim.
A different theory is that offenders take an unfair advantage over non offenders and punishment restores the just balance of benefits and burdens. Reformative theory law and legal definition uslegal, inc. Utilitarian justifications for punishment our first theoretical foray into punishment is the utilitarian perspective. The term crime does not, in modern criminal law, have any simple and universally accepted definition,1 though statutory definitions have been provided for certain purposes. During the heyday of liberalism in the 1960s and 1970s, the judicial and executive branches for example, parole boards wielded power in sentencing. In the retributivist theory of punishment, the punishment is seen as a form of payback for the crimes one has committed. Short essay on the preventive theory of punishment. The retributive theory seeks to punish offenders because they deserve to be.
Dadhikot9, bhaktapur bhaktapur, bhaktapur 6618 nepal. Theories of punishment for safe, orderly, peaceful and prosperous society to exist and flourish the following tools of theory are found to be good guides. Modern deterrence theories have their foun dation in classical criminological theory derived mainly from an essay on crimes and. Theories of punishment and mandatory minimum sentences the.
Holden university of texas at austin parental use of corporal punishment has been a contentious childrearing topic for thousands of years. Punishment can be explained by positive prevention theory to use the criminal justice. Generally, it is believed to be a firm of taking revenge and would not serve only penal purpose. Radelet abstract in this paper, i take a closer look at retribution, which is the primary justification for the death penalty today in the united states and the main component of the additional punishment imposed by the death penalty over and above life. The concept of penal reform had its birth from the reformative theory of punishment. One gave an overview of the utilitarian and retributive justifications of punishment. In lieu of an abstract, here is a brief excerpt of the content hegels idea of punishment peter g. Ii, november i978 retribution and the theory of punishments he idea that retribution, along with prevention of crime t and reformation of convicted criminals, plays a role in the nature and practice of punishment is a common theme in accounts of punishment at least since t. Unlike deterrence theory, an innocent can never be punished. Punishment is inflicted on a criminal in order to reform or educate him. This theory justifies capital punishment as an extreme form of punishment because of its determent effect. Retributive theory is based on rights, desert and justice. Punishment, the infliction of some kind of pain or loss upon a person for a misdeed i.